31 Thanksgiving Dinner Alternatives to Turkey

Honestly, anything can make for an alternative Thanksgiving dinner. It’s your house, your rules. Our only suggestion: Make it festive, fun, and at least a little decadent.
A classic Thanksgiving menu is all well and good, but one of our colleagues swears by serving nachos on the fourth Thursday of every November. If a big bloomin’ bird just isn’t ca-caw-caw-calling your name this year, serve a whole roast fish, pork tenderloin with sour-sweet cherry sauce, or a flaky carrot Wellington instead.
Or go completely rogue with lobster pasta or a big pot of chili. You can do that. Below, find vegetarian centerpieces, celebratory roasts, chicken dinners, and seafood mains for a Thanksgiving that looks a little different. BA’s Best Pumpkin Pie can stay.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Luciana Lamboy, Prop Styling by Gerri Williams1/31Carrot Wellington
Can carrots really count as a main course? They can when they’re roasted, glazed, and tucked into puff pastry with goat cheese, Gruyère, and walnuts. This Wellington feeds 8 to 10.
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Micah Morton, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness2/31Mushroom Bourguignon
Red wine, browned mushrooms, pearl onions, and carrots give this meatless braise plenty of heft. Ladle it over mashed potatoes for a vegetarian anchor to your Thanksgiving menu.
Photograph by Isa Zapata,Food Styling by Maggie Ruggiero,Prop Styling by Christine Keely3/31A Beautiful Cabbage Galette
Ruffled savoy cabbage, melty cheese, and a buttery cream cheese crust make this free-form tart worthy of the holiday table. Cut generous wedges for dinner and stick with savoy: Ordinary green cabbage won’t work here.
Photograph by Chris Simpson, Food Styling by Taneka Morris, Prop Styling by Gözde Eker4/31Pumpkin and Cheddar Strata
A make-ahead casserole, like this pumpkin-infused strata scented with nutmeg and herbs and balanced by sharp cheddar, is just what your holiday schedule needs. Assemble it the night before; bake it on Thanksgiving.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Styling by Mieko Takahashi, Prop Styling by Alex Massillon5/31Manicotti
Turkey isn’t the only holiday cooking project worth clearing the counter for. Delicate homemade crepes are rolled around ricotta, mozzarella, and Parmesan, then baked in marinara. Make the batter and filling a day ahead to split up the work.
Photo by Emma Fishman, Food Styling by Susie Theodorou6/31Vegetarian Enchiladas
Kale, pinto beans, and charred poblanos make these cheesy enchiladas a satisfying holiday main for four to six. Get a head start by making the charred salsa verde up to three days ahead.
Photo by Ted + Chelsea Cavanaugh, Food Styling by Simon Andrews7/31Risotto With Mushrooms and Thyme
This autumnal risotto works as a standalone dinner or alongside your favorite Thanksgiving sides. Set the table with shallow bowls and pick a fall salad full of color and crunch to balance the buttery rice.
Photograph by Jenny Huang, Food styling by Susie Theodorou, prop styling by Martha Bernabe8/31Char Siu Wellington
British beef Wellington meets Cantonese barbecue-style pork in Peter Som’s pastry-wrapped centerpiece. A shiitake mushroom filling and gravy made from the marinade complete the picture; assemble the Wellington a day ahead.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Maggie Ruggiero, Prop Styling by Christine Keely9/31Red Wine–Braised Short Ribs
These impossibly tender short ribs are begging to be served with mashed potatoes and buttery milk buns with garlic butter. Give them what they want—and give yourself a head start by braising the ribs the day before Thanksgiving.
Alex Lau10/31Roast Pork Belly with Chile Vinegar
Turkey skin has competition. Tender pork belly, crisp crackling, and a hard cider pan sauce make a persuasive case for skipping the bird. Pass the chile vinegar to cut through the richness; this roast feeds 8 to 12.
Photograph by Eva Kolenko. Food styling by Susie Theodorou. Set design by Kira Corbin. On set producer: Jennifer Thomas.11/31Prime Rib Roast With Habanero Crema
Ayesha Curry’s spice-crusted prime rib takes its cues from her mother’s braised oxtails, with habanero crema on the side. Prefer a simpler garlic-and-rosemary approach? Try this Low-and-Slow Rib Roast.
Alex Lau12/31Roast Beef Tenderloin With Garlic and Rosemary
For a roast-and-sides Thanksgiving without the turkey, garlic-and-rosemary-rubbed beef tenderloin makes an excellent centerpiece. Rosemary butter dresses the sliced roast, while tangy horseradish yogurt gives everyone something to swipe their next bite through.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Styling by Taneka Morris, Prop Styling by Dayna Seman13/31Pork Shoulder Inasal
Toasted rice, fried onions, and garlic form a dark, peppery crust on this slow-braised pork shoulder. Set out the big platter and pass the coconut-vinegar pan sauce; this roast feeds 8 to 12.
Photo by Andrew Purcell, Prop Styling by Paige Hicks, Food Styling by Carrie Purcell14/31Leg of Lamb With Garlic and Rosemary
Maybe save the brown sugar-glazed ham for Christmas? This whole leg of lamb makes for a centerpiece that’s just as showstopping. And, like ham and turkey, leftover lamb can be deliciously repurposed in sandwiches.
Photograph by Jessica Pettway, Food Styling by Judy Kim, Prop Styling by Stephanie Yeh15/31Pork Tenderloin With Agrodolce Cherries
A platter of sliced pork tenderloin with glossy cherries and browned shallots has plenty of holiday presence without a long roast. Honey and red wine vinegar give the sauce its sweet-sour bite, and frozen cherries are welcome here.
Photo by Alex Lau16/31Pork Tamales Rojos
If you’re going to make tamales, it’s a good idea to make a lot of them. Better yet, turn the process into a party, with everyone spreading masa and folding corn husks around the red chile pork filling.
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Micah Morton, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness17/31Brussels Sprout Pasta
This pasta packs a whole spectrum of holiday flavors into each bite, with crumbles of Italian sausage, shreds of brussels sprouts, and toasted pecans. Streamlining dinner into one dish leaves you more time for Thanksgiving pies.
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Micah Morton, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness18/31Weeknight Pumpkin Chili
For some people, spending all Thanksgiving in the kitchen sounds like a good time. For everyone else, there’s this beef-and-bean chili. A can of pumpkin purée thickens the broth, keeping things seasonal without calling for a single roasting pan.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Stying by Judy Kim, Prop Styling by Marina Bevilacqua19/31Fried Chicken With Cranberry-Mustard Sauce
Give homemade fried chicken an even more festive angle with sage and thyme in the dredge and cranberry-mustard sauce for dipping. Start the buttermilk marinade the day before.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Stying by Judy Kim, Prop Styling by Marina Bevilacqua20/31Pomegranate-and-Honey-Glazed Duck With Rice
This whole roast duck comes with a built-in Thanksgiving side: The duck fat drippings go into basmati rice that cooks while the bird rests. Plan for an overnight dry brine before the glossy pomegranate-honey glaze gets its moment.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Leslie Raney Garetto, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness21/31Schmaltzy Chicken and Stuffing Skillet
Cooking for a smaller crowd? This skillet delivers the stuffing and the bird—chicken thighs, in this case—in one tidy package. Rendered chicken fat enriches the boxed stuffing mix, with dried cranberries and lemon zest brightening things up.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Styling by Judy Kim, Prop Styling by Marina Bevilacuqua22/31Chile-Vinegar-Marinated Cornish Game Hens
Two diminutive birds make a festive roast for four. A fiery guajillo chile, ginger, and vinegar marinade flavors both the hens and the potatoes beneath them, so the platter arrives with its own very good side.
Marcus Nilsson23/31Cast-Iron Roast Chicken With Crispy Potatoes
You just need to make green beans, because this Thanksgiving main is already a two-in-one: Thinly sliced potatoes cook beneath a whole chicken, catching its drippings and crisping around the edges in the same cast-iron skillet.
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Michelle Gatton, and Prop Styling by Christina Allen24/31Buldak Chicken Parm
If your Thanksgiving table could use a little red sauce (and spice), skip the whole bird in favor of this take on chicken parm. Gochujang and gochugaru bring the heat; melted mozzarella keeps things gloriously gooey.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Micah Marie Morton, Prop Styling by Christine Keely25/31Paella de Pollo con Verduras
José Andrés turns chicken wings and a colorful assortment of vegetables into a grand centerpiece, with saffron and smoked paprika flavoring the rice. You’ll need a 15" paella pan or comparably sized two-handled cast-iron or cast-aluminum pan.
Photo by Laura Murray, Food styling by Kat Boystova, prop styling by Allie Wist26/31Lobster Pasta
There’s nothing like pasta to stretch a spendy ingredient (hello, lobster). Serve with a big crunchy salad with Italian dressing and garlic confit toast that diners can pass around for Thanksgiving party vibes.
Photo by Emma Fishman, Food Styling by D'mytrek Brown, Small Bowls by Meilen Ceramics27/31Whole Fish Ssam
Presenting a whole fish at the holiday table is wildly celebratory, even when you’re cooking for just two or three. Bring out lettuce wraps, kimchi, rice, and ssamjang so everyone can build each bite a little differently.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Rebecca Jurkevich, Prop Styling Christine Keely28/31Salmon With Sizzled Nut Salsa
A large roasted salmon fillet looks right at home on a holiday platter, especially under a crunchy, garlicky nut salsa. Make the salsa up to four days ahead, then roast the fish when it’s time for dinner.
Photograph by Isa Zapata, food styling by Emilie Fosnocht, prop styling by Emma Ringness29/31Stuffing-Crusted Fish
The stuffing doesn’t have to be a side. Here, crushed boxed stuffing mix joins Parmesan, lemon zest, and parsley in a crisp crust for mustard-coated white fish. Dinner lands on the table in 25 minutes.
Photo by David Williams30/31Cá Kho (Fish With Coconut Caramel)
This dark, glossy coconut caramel—savory with fish sauce and garlic, sharp with pickled jalapeño brine—turns pan-seared salmon into a holiday-worthy main. Serve with rice to catch every last bit of sauce.
Photograph by Emma Fishman, food styling by Micah Morton, prop styling by Stephanie Yeh31/31Shrimp and Grits With Fennel Potlikker
Like many of the best Thanksgiving dishes, this one starts with a good stock. Carla Hall builds a fennel potlikker with celery, onions, and Pernod before layering those flavors into a hearty bowl of shrimp and grits.
.jpg)